While watching the video of Michael Moore attempting to justify socialism when it came to economics, one thing that completely blew my mind was when Moore stated “All great religions say essentially the same thing that Marx said, the rich man is not suppose to come into the room and take 9 slices of pie and leave one slice for everyone else to fight over”. First off, when it comes to economics all great religions don’t say the same thing. Each worldview holds to its own philosophy and theology which will impact their view when it comes to economics. Differences are clearly present in different worldviews, thus no economic system could be completely agreed upon. In Moore’s attempt to group all religions into one category, he fails to distinguish between the different worldviews and how these worldviews different in many ideas regarding the economic system. For example, lets distinguish the differences between Christianity (Stewardship of Property) and Marxism (Socialism) since these seem to be the 2 religions Moore alludes to the most. The Bible as a whole supports an economic system that respects private property and the work ethic (Proverbs 31, Isaiah 65:21-22, Jeremiah 32:43-44, Acts 5:1-4 and Ephesians 4:28). Both the Old and New Testament teach about private property and good stewardship of property ( Genesis 23:13-20, Deuteronomy 8, Isaiah 65:21-22, Proverbs 31). Christians believe that God is the ultimate owner of everything and that human beings have been given the responsibility to manage and care for His creation. Socialism on the other hand believes in an economic system in which the ownership and operation of the means of production and distribution are controlled by the government, which is the exact opposite of what Christians believe. So if Christians believe and respects private property and believes that God is the ultimate owner and controller of everything, and Marxists believe that citizen should not have the right to private property and that the government is the ultimate controller how is this “essentially the same”? When it comes to Moore’s pie story, why should a person who goes to school extra to pursue the career they want, such as a doctor, get paid the same amount as a person who works at a grocery store? The Bible clearly teaches that workers deserve their pay, and those that work hard are rewarded, while those that are lazy remain poor (Proverbs 10:4, 14:23; Luke 10:7). Why would I believe that different positions, such as doctors and grocery store employees, deserve the same pay and benefits? When it’s clear one profession deserves more than the other. A socialist economy would ultimately fail because why would anyone want to pursue a higher profession, when they could work less and reap the same benefits as a lower profession? A socialist economy would ultimately take away work from our society, rather than improve it.
No comments:
Post a Comment