Wednesday, March 2, 2011

Islamic and Christian views and approaches to law.

Christians believe that God gave us divine laws and the means of discovering them.  When talking about the Christian view of law Carl F.H Henry states “God is the only Legislator. Earthly rulers and legislative bodies are alike accountable to Him from whom stems all obligation- religious, ethical and civil” (283). We ask Christians acknowledge this truth when we examine the assumptions and failings of all human- centered legal systems, especially those who deny God as the law giver. When we fail to consider law as sacred, we also fail to consider it binding. If in our fallen condition we create our own laws, we are likely to revise them to better suit our selfish needs. A weak foundation for law creates a weak foundation for morality. Christians believe that moral code and law is grounded in the immutable nature of God, a firm foundation that does not flex or evolve.  Christians believe in Natural law, which includes God’s general revelation to us of bother physical and moral laws.  Christians believe that we can know God’s will or natural law thought our conscience, our inherent sense of right and wrong. The general revelation of natural law is grounded in God. Understood properly, natural law explains why each of us is accountable to God for our actions: we know a transcendent law exists, yet we consciously flaunty it. In addition to natural law, Christian legal theory must take into account God’s special revelation of His moral order and divine law, the Bible. Natural law gives us a general concept of right and wrong, while the Bible fleshes out the skeletal framework, telling us what God considers moral and lawful. God’s general revelation and special revelation considered together, allow for the implementation of a legal system that is independent of human wisdom. General and special revelations are accessible to everyone and provide the guidance necessary to create a reasonably just legal system.  Christians also believe in Divine law. Divine law, based on general and special revelation, provides a definite means for evaluation human laws.  Christians view Divine law as the basis for declaring a human law just or unjust.  According to God’s plan, the responsibility of governments is to encourage people to obey divine law by punishing wrongdoers and protecting those who live in accordance with God’s law (Romans 13:3-4). Christian law consists of five basic precepts. First, the source of all divine law is the character and nature of God. Second, the moral order proceeds form and reflects the character of God- His holiness, justice, truth, love, and mercy. Gods moral order is as real as the physical moral.  Thirdly, we are created in God’s image and significant. Our life is not an afterthought or an accident. God established human government to protect human life, rights and dignity (Genesis 9:6, Romans 130. Fourthly, when Jesus Christ took on human form, human life assumed even greater significance. God the creator became God the Redeemer (John 1:14). Finally, God through Christ will judge the whole human race according to His standard of good and evil (Acts 17:31, Romans 2:16, 2 Corinthians 5:10). Christian law is based on God’s unchanging character as an absolute foundation rather than on a foundation that evolves and changes over time based solely on societal concerns. Christian law ensures specific, absolute human rights that other worldviews that deny God’s existence cannot guarantee. Christian human rights are based on specific duties prescribed in the Bible. God assigns us specific rights, and we are responsible for obey God and protecting our rights as well as the rights of others. The Bible provides specific instructions for establishing earthly legal systems and He requires such systems to be orderly and equitable. God expects our legal systems to hold individuals responsible for their actions and to work to restore God’s order wherever possible.
Shari’ah is the name of the body of laws Muslims believe are applicable, while figh is the human endeavor to understand and apply those laws. The goal of Muslim jurists is not law making but figh- understanding or knowledge of law deemed to exist already. Some of the legal pronouncements encased in Shari’ah include the stoning of adulterers, cutting off hands of thieves and killing apostates. Shari’ah law is Islamic law derived from the Qur’an and Hadith and applied to the public and private lives of Muslims within Islamic states. Shari’ah law governs may aspects of day to day life- politics, economics, banking, business, contracts, social issues, ect.  In contrast to the Christian worldview that affirms God reveals both His will and Himself, Islam holds that “God has not revealed Himself and His nature, but rather His law”(292). There are four main tributaries for Islamic Shari’ah: The Qur’an, the Sunnah, the Ijima’, and Qiyas (analogical reasoning). The Islamic Shari’ah defines five categories of human behavior: that which is commanded, recommended, indifferent, disapproved and forbidden.
1.       Those acts that are commanded are required or obligatory. Disobedience is worthy of punishment (in this life and the next) and obedience is rewarded in eternity. These would include the five pillars of Islam as well as participation is jihad
2.       Those acts that are recommended are deemed commendable, but are not required. Although failure to do them is not punishable, accomplishing recommended acts is worthy or reward. These include charitable acts above and beyond those commanded, extra prayers or fasting, and other good deeds.
3.       Those acts that are forbidden are prohibited. To do them is to be worthy of punishment. To avoid them is to be worthy of reward.
4.       Those acts that are disapproved are discouraged to one degree or another. While doing them does not result in punishment, avoiding them may be worthy of reward in the afterlife.
5.       Those acts that are indifferent are without either positive or negative consequences. Neither doing them or refusing them gains punishment or reward.
Islam stands in contrast both the biblical revelation of human sinfulness and the importance of a division of powers. The result is that nations with predominately Muslim population tend toward dictatorships or monarchies and in consequence lack personal freedom. In contrast to the Biblical Christian view of the nature of man, the Muslim community cannot find a similar basis for individual freedom within its religion.  The idea of freedom of expression is not part of Muslim legal tradition. Only a biblical worldview provides a basis for law that respects both human dignity and human depravity.

No comments:

Post a Comment